Commodity Origins

Are crop yields different in El Niño and La Niña years?

Across 132 yield series (the 30 crops with the most harvested land, in up to their 5 largest producing countries), 15 differ from the other years in El Niño years by more than 95% of random shuffles of the phase labels would, and 12 in La Niña years. With 264 tests, chance alone would give about 13, so the 27 passes are about 2.0 times the chance count. The largest El Niño gaps are Australia's rape or colza seed (23% lower than in other years), Australia's barley (21% lower than in other years), Australia's oats (16% lower than in other years); 3 of the 15 El Niño passes are Australian crops. For most country and crop pairs the data do not show a yield difference tied to either phase.

Method: each calendar year is labelled with the phase used on the El Niño and prices page (NOAA's Oceanic Niño Index, calendar-year mean: +0.5 or higher El Niño, -0.5 or lower La Niña, otherwise neutral). For each crop and country, a year's yield (FAOSTAT, kilograms per hectare) is compared with the average of up to 4 years before and 4 after it, which removes the long upward drift in yields without fitting a curve; the first and last three years drop out. The gap is the average of that difference in a phase's years minus its average in all other years. Chance benchmark: the labels are shuffled across the same years 10,000 times, keeping how many of each phase there are, and the chance column is the share of shuffles with a gap at least as large in size. A pair is included only with at least 30 usable years and 5 years in each phase.

The crops and countries come from a rule (the largest harvested area, then the largest producers by output in 2024), not from picking results. The only change after a first run was to leave out FAOSTAT group totals such as "Pulses, Total", which are not single crops. Every pair is tested for both phases, so 264 tests were run, and the 27 that pass include the chance passes. Of the El Niño passes, 12 of 15 have lower yields in El Niño years; of the La Niña passes, 4 of 12 have higher yields in La Niña years. This is a description of two series, not a measurement of weather's effect: a calendar year can hold the end of one growing season and the start of another, and the monsoon, dry seasons and harvests fall at different times in different countries.

Every series

Yield deviation in El Niño, La Niña and neutral years by crop and country
CropCountryShare of world outputEl Niño yearsLa Niña yearsNeutral yearsEl Niño gapChance, El NiñoLa Niña gapChance, La NiñaYears used
BarleyAustralia9%−16.7% (12)+4.5% (14)+4.4% (32)−21.1%under 0.001+5.9%0.3291964 to 2021
YamsTogo1%−4.8% (12)+6.9% (14)−1.2% (32)−6.0%0.039+9.1%under 0.0011964 to 2021
Chick peas, dryTurkey (Türkiye)3%+4.6% (12)−5.8% (14)+0.6% (32)+6.0%0.016−7.4%0.0021964 to 2021
Maize (corn)China24%−3.9% (12)+0.7% (14)+1.2% (32)−4.9%0.003+0.8%0.5971964 to 2021
Rape or colza seedAustralia7%−19.2% (10)+2.5% (14)+4.3% (27)−22.9%0.004+4.6%0.5301971 to 2021
Chick peas, dryMyanmar2%+7.2% (12)−3.1% (14)−1.4% (32)+9.1%0.004−4.0%0.1861964 to 2021
Seed cotton, unginnedBrazil12%−2.5% (12)+5.5% (14)−3.5% (32)−1.8%0.622+8.7%0.0081964 to 2021
Coconuts, in shellPhilippines22%+4.3% (12)−7.8% (14)+1.2% (32)+5.8%0.150−9.9%0.0091964 to 2021
OatsAustralia6%−12.2% (12)+5.0% (14)+3.3% (32)−16.0%0.015+6.0%0.3421964 to 2021
RiceVietnam5%−1.4% (12)+2.4% (14)−1.2% (32)−1.3%0.444+3.6%0.0211964 to 2021
Soya beansChina5%−3.8% (12)+0.8% (14)+1.4% (32)−4.9%0.021+0.8%0.6951964 to 2021
Sesame seedPakistan7%−6.6% (12)+3.8% (14)−0.1% (32)−7.7%0.021+5.6%0.0751964 to 2021
Lentils, dryCanada31%+9.7% (9)−13.7% (10)+2.6% (27)+11.4%0.167−18.1%0.0221976 to 2021
Groundnuts, excluding shelledChina34%−3.7% (12)+2.3% (14)+0.3% (32)−4.6%0.023+3.1%0.1051964 to 2021
MilletChina9%−6.4% (12)−3.4% (14)+4.2% (32)−8.3%0.024−4.7%0.1881964 to 2021
BarleyCanada6%+1.5% (12)−5.3% (14)+1.8% (32)+1.9%0.589−7.1%0.0271964 to 2021
WheatCanada5%+1.3% (12)−6.3% (14)+2.4% (32)+1.6%0.694−8.4%0.0301964 to 2021
Rape or colza seedIndia15%+0.3% (12)+5.6% (14)−2.9% (32)+0.6%0.877+7.7%0.0331964 to 2021
PotatoesIndia15%+4.0% (12)+0.7% (14)−2.2% (32)+5.3%0.034+1.2%0.6111964 to 2021
Rape or colza seedCanada22%+2.5% (12)−5.6% (14)+1.3% (32)+3.3%0.357−7.2%0.0341964 to 2021
Cashew nuts, in shellGhana5%+3.5% (6)−5.3% (6)+0.5% (20)+4.3%0.177−6.5%0.0391990 to 2021
Soya beansIndia4%−8.4% (12)+2.7% (14)+1.4% (32)−10.2%0.046+4.0%0.4191964 to 2021
Cassava, freshGhana8%+1.3% (12)−3.4% (14)+0.5% (32)+2.0%0.367−4.1%0.0481964 to 2021
RiceIndia27%−3.4% (12)+2.1% (14)−0.1% (32)−4.0%0.049+3.0%0.1201964 to 2021
Seed cotton, unginnedIndia21%−5.8% (12)+4.1% (14)−0.3% (32)−6.8%0.050+5.9%0.0681964 to 2021
Mangoes, guavas and mangosteensBrazil4%+2.9% (12)−4.3% (14)+0.1% (32)+4.1%0.153−5.1%0.0591964 to 2021
Seed cotton, unginnedUnited States13%+4.1% (12)−1.0% (14)−1.0% (32)+5.1%0.064−1.4%0.6021964 to 2021
Coconuts, in shellBrazil5%+4.4% (12)−5.7% (14)−1.3% (32)+7.0%0.065−6.0%0.0971964 to 2021
BarleyFrance7%+4.5% (12)+1.5% (14)−2.0% (32)+5.4%0.068+1.8%0.5331964 to 2021
Mangoes, guavas and mangosteensIndonesia7%−0.3% (12)+6.2% (14)−3.2% (32)+0.0%0.998+8.6%0.0691964 to 2021
MilletIndia41%−6.5% (12)+0.8% (14)+1.9% (32)−8.1%0.070+1.2%0.7791964 to 2021
MilletNiger12%−0.2% (12)−6.0% (14)+2.5% (32)−0.1%0.990−7.8%0.0781964 to 2021
Cocoa beansGhana10%−4.7% (12)+0.3% (14)+1.5% (32)−5.8%0.095+0.5%0.8841964 to 2021
OatsCanada15%+0.5% (12)−3.6% (14)+1.1% (32)+0.8%0.778−4.5%0.0961964 to 2021
Lentils, dryIndia23%+3.7% (12)−0.1% (14)−1.8% (32)+5.0%0.099+0.2%0.9331964 to 2021
GrapesChina22%−3.8% (12)+2.6% (14)−1.5% (32)−3.6%0.246+4.8%0.1001964 to 2021
GrapesUnited States6%+3.1% (12)+4.4% (14)−2.5% (32)+3.5%0.319+5.3%0.1021964 to 2021
Peas, dryIndia8%+5.3% (12)−3.3% (14)−1.2% (32)+7.2%0.108−3.9%0.3691964 to 2021
Coffee, greenColombia8%+5.5% (12)−2.6% (14)−0.6% (32)+6.7%0.109−3.7%0.3581964 to 2021
Cocoa beansIvory Coast (Côte d'Ivoire)36%−3.0% (12)+2.6% (14)+0.5% (32)−4.1%0.112+3.1%0.1991964 to 2021
Maize (corn)India3%−4.0% (12)+1.9% (14)+0.4% (32)−4.8%0.117+2.7%0.3561964 to 2021
Groundnuts, excluding shelledIndia21%−6.8% (12)+1.6% (14)+1.2% (32)−8.1%0.117+2.6%0.5931964 to 2021
Soya beansUnited States30%+2.9% (12)−2.4% (14)−0.1% (32)+3.7%0.118−3.1%0.1641964 to 2021
Seed cotton, unginnedPakistan5%+0.8% (12)+5.1% (14)−2.0% (32)+0.7%0.868+6.3%0.1221964 to 2021
SorghumUnited States14%+5.8% (12)−0.5% (14)−0.1% (32)+6.0%0.135−2.0%0.6001964 to 2021
YamsGhana11%+5.8% (12)−5.3% (14)+0.1% (32)+7.3%0.140−6.9%0.1431964 to 2021
Coffee, greenBrazil30%+7.5% (12)+2.3% (14)−3.9% (32)+9.5%0.148+3.1%0.6121964 to 2021
Cocoa beansEcuador8%−4.0% (12)+7.5% (14)−1.7% (32)−5.1%0.479+9.8%0.1611964 to 2021
Sweet potatoesNigeria5%−1.3% (12)−4.0% (14)+2.0% (32)−1.5%0.691−5.0%0.1651964 to 2021
Chick peas, dryAustralia13%−15.9% (7)+4.4% (8)+0.1% (21)−17.2%0.166+8.2%0.4911986 to 2021
Seed cotton, unginnedChina26%+1.4% (12)+3.9% (14)−1.7% (32)+1.4%0.698+4.8%0.1671964 to 2021
Plantains and cooking bananasGhana10%−0.8% (12)−1.7% (14)+0.8% (32)−0.9%0.563−2.0%0.1691964 to 2021
Coconuts, in shellVietnam3%−3.4% (12)+1.4% (14)−0.2% (32)−3.7%0.174+2.5%0.3171964 to 2021
Lentils, dryAustralia16%−23.2% (6)+8.7% (6)+9.4% (19)−32.4%0.177+7.1%0.7641991 to 2021
OlivesPortugal6%+13.5% (6)−4.2% (8)−4.1% (20)+17.6%0.183−4.2%0.7231988 to 2021
Cashew nuts, in shellTanzania12%−4.6% (12)+7.5% (14)−2.2% (32)−5.4%0.509+10.3%0.1841964 to 2021
Sunflower seedChina5%+3.6% (12)−3.0% (14)−0.7% (32)+5.0%0.186−3.5%0.3311964 to 2021
Sweet potatoesChina56%−1.9% (12)+1.4% (14)+0.1% (32)−2.5%0.186+1.8%0.3001964 to 2021
YamsBenin4%−1.2% (12)+2.6% (14)−0.3% (32)−1.8%0.490+3.1%0.2111964 to 2021
Maize (corn)United States31%+3.4% (12)−1.7% (14)−0.3% (32)+4.1%0.217−2.4%0.4401964 to 2021
Sunflower seedTurkey (Türkiye)4%+3.2% (12)−0.1% (14)−0.2% (32)+3.4%0.228−0.8%0.7611964 to 2021
Cow peas, dryNiger27%+2.3% (12)−9.4% (14)+0.5% (32)+4.8%0.595−10.4%0.2301964 to 2021
GrapesFrance6%−3.5% (12)+2.3% (14)+0.4% (32)−4.5%0.231+2.9%0.4031964 to 2021
OlivesItaly10%+6.5% (12)+3.3% (14)−4.4% (32)+8.6%0.244+4.7%0.5081964 to 2021
Soya beansBrazil36%+2.2% (12)+3.0% (14)−1.9% (32)+2.6%0.454+3.8%0.2491964 to 2021
Sesame seedMyanmar11%−1.1% (12)+2.5% (14)−2.0% (32)−0.5%0.905+4.2%0.2501964 to 2021
SorghumMexico7%+0.2% (12)−2.3% (14)+0.5% (32)+0.5%0.846−2.8%0.2541964 to 2021
WheatIndia14%+1.4% (12)+0.0% (14)−1.2% (32)+2.2%0.255+0.5%0.8051964 to 2021
Plantains and cooking bananasUganda27%+1.8% (12)+1.7% (14)−1.4% (32)+2.3%0.269+2.2%0.2591964 to 2021
Peas, dryUnited States5%−5.4% (12)−3.0% (14)+4.6% (32)−7.7%0.262−4.9%0.4561964 to 2021
Beans, dryTanzania5%+2.9% (12)+2.2% (14)−2.0% (32)+3.6%0.274+2.9%0.3811964 to 2021
SorghumIndia8%−2.6% (12)+2.1% (14)−0.5% (32)−2.9%0.349+3.1%0.2911964 to 2021
OlivesTurkey (Türkiye)16%−7.3% (12)−10.0% (14)+6.5% (32)−8.7%0.501−12.7%0.2911964 to 2021
Lentils, dryUnited States5%+0.0% (12)−4.2% (14)+3.4% (32)−1.0%0.882−6.7%0.3061964 to 2021
Mangoes, guavas and mangosteensChina7%+3.0% (12)−2.4% (14)−0.6% (32)+4.1%0.307−2.7%0.4671964 to 2021
Plantains and cooking bananasCameroon11%+4.2% (12)+0.6% (14)−2.3% (32)+5.6%0.308+1.1%0.8301964 to 2021
Cow peas, dryNigeria42%−6.8% (12)−1.8% (14)+1.9% (32)−7.6%0.308−1.3%0.8581964 to 2021
Mangoes, guavas and mangosteensIndia45%+1.9% (12)−1.7% (14)−0.2% (32)+2.6%0.317−2.1%0.3931964 to 2021
Coffee, greenVietnam18%+3.3% (12)−4.3% (14)+0.6% (32)+4.3%0.475−5.7%0.3171964 to 2021
Coconuts, in shellIndonesia27%−1.1% (12)+0.4% (14)+0.1% (32)−1.3%0.322+0.6%0.6551964 to 2021
RiceBangladesh7%−0.6% (12)+0.6% (14)−0.5% (32)−0.5%0.732+1.2%0.3251964 to 2021
Rape or colza seedChina19%+2.7% (12)+0.4% (14)−0.4% (32)+2.9%0.328−0.1%0.9801964 to 2021
Beans, dryBrazil10%+0.7% (12)+1.4% (14)−1.3% (32)+1.2%0.613+2.2%0.3291964 to 2021
RiceIndonesia6%+0.6% (12)+0.1% (14)−0.7% (32)+1.0%0.335+0.5%0.6261964 to 2021
Cassava, freshNigeria18%−2.9% (12)−1.0% (14)+1.6% (32)−3.7%0.340−1.4%0.7021964 to 2021
OlivesSpain36%+10.8% (7)−0.7% (10)−0.9% (22)+11.6%0.342−2.6%0.8061983 to 2021
GrapesItaly10%−1.7% (12)−0.1% (14)+1.6% (32)−2.8%0.350−0.8%0.7691964 to 2021
Peas, dryChina11%−1.2% (12)−2.4% (14)+1.6% (32)−1.5%0.684−3.2%0.3591964 to 2021
Cassava, freshBrazil6%+0.9% (12)+0.7% (14)−0.6% (32)+1.1%0.359+0.9%0.4241964 to 2021
Soya beansArgentina12%+1.0% (12)+3.6% (14)−1.0% (32)+0.6%0.892+4.0%0.3601964 to 2021
Groundnuts, excluding shelledUnited States5%+0.5% (12)+2.3% (14)−0.5% (32)+0.1%0.966+2.5%0.3691964 to 2021
PotatoesUnited States5%+0.6% (12)−0.4% (14)−0.1% (32)+0.8%0.372−0.5%0.5841964 to 2021
Maize (corn)Brazil9%+1.5% (12)−2.2% (14)−0.1% (32)+2.2%0.445−2.5%0.3751964 to 2021
YamsNigeria71%−3.8% (12)−3.3% (14)+2.4% (32)−4.5%0.396−4.0%0.4151964 to 2021
Cassava, freshDR Congo (Democratic Republic of the Congo)14%+0.2% (12)+0.4% (14)−0.2% (32)+0.2%0.768+0.5%0.4041964 to 2021
Cashew nuts, in shellIvory Coast (Côte d'Ivoire)22%−5.3% (12)−0.7% (14)−0.8% (32)−4.5%0.418+1.3%0.8121964 to 2021
RiceChina25%+0.0% (12)+0.7% (14)+0.1% (32)−0.3%0.774+0.7%0.4271964 to 2021
Sweet potatoesAngola2%+2.7% (12)+0.3% (14)−1.4% (32)+3.6%0.428+0.6%0.8951964 to 2021
Cocoa beansNigeria7%−1.8% (12)−2.3% (14)+2.6% (32)−2.9%0.572−3.6%0.4401964 to 2021
Mangoes, guavas and mangosteensMexico4%−1.6% (12)−2.5% (14)+1.4% (32)−1.9%0.653−3.1%0.4481964 to 2021
Sesame seedNigeria7%−1.6% (12)−5.8% (14)+1.8% (32)−1.1%0.905−6.7%0.4661964 to 2021
Plantains and cooking bananasDR Congo (Democratic Republic of the Congo)11%+0.4% (12)+0.2% (14)−0.1% (32)+0.4%0.468+0.2%0.6671964 to 2021
Cocoa beansIndonesia12%+2.8% (12)−1.5% (14)−1.7% (32)+4.5%0.475−1.1%0.8631964 to 2021
WheatChina18%−0.8% (12)+1.0% (14)−0.1% (32)−1.0%0.593+1.3%0.4891964 to 2021
MilletNigeria5%+1.1% (12)+2.8% (14)−1.7% (32)+1.4%0.803+3.7%0.5121964 to 2021
Beans, dryUnited States5%+0.6% (12)−1.5% (14)−0.4% (32)+1.3%0.565−1.4%0.5141964 to 2021
BarleyGermany7%+0.4% (12)+1.2% (14)−0.6% (32)+0.4%0.865+1.5%0.5201964 to 2021
Beans, dryMyanmar8%−1.2% (12)+0.9% (14)−1.0% (32)−0.7%0.827+2.0%0.5291964 to 2021
Coffee, greenIndonesia7%−0.4% (12)−0.9% (14)+0.5% (32)−0.5%0.825−1.2%0.5481964 to 2021
OatsFinland5%+2.0% (12)−1.7% (14)−0.0% (32)+2.6%0.554−2.2%0.5841964 to 2021
Maize (corn)Argentina5%−1.5% (12)+1.3% (14)+0.8% (32)−2.4%0.561+1.1%0.7841964 to 2021
Coconuts, in shellIndia22%−0.9% (12)+0.9% (14)−0.1% (32)−1.1%0.639+1.2%0.5841964 to 2021
Sweet potatoesTanzania2%+1.4% (12)+1.9% (14)−3.2% (32)+3.0%0.690+3.8%0.5871964 to 2021
Groundnuts, excluding shelledMyanmar3%+0.5% (12)−0.2% (14)−1.1% (32)+1.3%0.593+0.5%0.8411964 to 2021
OatsPoland7%−0.9% (12)+1.2% (14)−0.5% (32)−1.0%0.775+1.8%0.6001964 to 2021
PotatoesChina24%+0.4% (12)+0.8% (14)−0.6% (32)+0.6%0.816+1.1%0.6241964 to 2021
Cow peas, dryBurkina Faso7%−0.4% (12)+0.2% (14)+0.1% (32)−0.6%0.625+0.2%0.8611964 to 2021
WheatUnited States7%−0.1% (12)−0.6% (14)+0.4% (32)−0.3%0.913−0.9%0.6691964 to 2021
Chick peas, dryIndia65%+0.2% (12)−1.3% (14)−0.0% (32)+0.6%0.873−1.3%0.7041964 to 2021
YamsIvory Coast (Côte d'Ivoire)8%−0.4% (12)+0.6% (14)−0.1% (32)−0.5%0.831+0.8%0.7051964 to 2021
Groundnuts, excluding shelledNigeria7%+1.1% (12)−2.2% (14)−0.7% (32)+2.3%0.706−2.0%0.7281964 to 2021
MilletMali6%−1.3% (12)−1.1% (14)+1.6% (32)−2.1%0.711−1.9%0.7151964 to 2021
GrapesSpain7%−0.3% (12)+2.1% (14)+1.5% (32)−2.0%0.743+1.1%0.8541964 to 2021
OlivesEgypt6%−1.5% (12)+0.7% (14)−0.1% (32)−1.7%0.763+1.2%0.8241964 to 2021
SorghumNigeria10%−1.5% (12)+0.0% (14)+0.1% (32)−1.6%0.770+0.4%0.9391964 to 2021
Cashew nuts, in shellVietnam7%−1.3% (12)−0.1% (14)+0.7% (32)−1.7%0.785−0.3%0.9631964 to 2021
Sunflower seedArgentina7%−0.7% (12)−0.2% (14)+0.4% (32)−0.9%0.802−0.3%0.9231964 to 2021
Beans, dryIndia27%−1.0% (12)−0.2% (14)−0.3% (32)−0.7%0.821+0.3%0.9271964 to 2021
Sesame seedIndia13%+0.7% (12)−0.4% (14)+0.0% (32)+0.8%0.843−0.6%0.8751964 to 2021
Peas, dryCanada21%+0.1% (12)+0.1% (14)+1.1% (32)−0.7%0.911−0.7%0.9041964 to 2021
Cassava, freshThailand8%−0.3% (12)−0.1% (14)−0.1% (32)−0.2%0.931+0.0%0.9871964 to 2021
Cashew nuts, in shellIndia19%−0.0% (12)−0.1% (14)+0.0% (32)−0.0%0.992−0.1%0.9561964 to 2021

The three phase columns are the average difference of a year's yield from the years around it; brackets give the number of years in the phase. A gap is a phase's average minus the average of all other years, and the chance column tests that gap. 25 of the 132 series pass at 0.05 for at least one phase. A pass is not a finding that the phase caused the difference, and with 264 tests about 13 would pass anyway.

FAOSTAT Crops and livestock products (yield, kg per hectare), 2024 and earlier; world and country shares of output are for 2024. Phase labels: NOAA Climate Prediction Center, Oceanic Nino Index (public domain). Crop names are FAOSTAT's. Yields of the former Soviet republics begin in the 1990s, so those countries have fewer usable years and some fall below the minimum. For the other direction, how phases line up with price changes, see El Niño and prices; for what the phenomenon is, the explainer.

More patterns

All 54 reports are listed on the patterns page.

Every figure is computed from the same tables as the commodity pages. The full set is in patterns.json, and single facts from it appear each day on the facts page.